Thursday, March 10, 2011

The Circular nature of atheist ideology

Atheism want to pass itself off as "scientific." So they cling to the scienistic idea that science is the only form of knowledge. They truncate the nature of truth to that which can be produced by their own methods. Anything else they reduce until they lose the phenomena. So at that point atheism can't have truth all it can have is circular reasoning.


atheist: "there is nothing beyond the materiel realm. There are no proof of the SN, No evidence for God, no nothing.

Believer--Here's some, here's a whole pile facts from which one might deduce the existence of God.

Atheist: "those can't be evidence for SN or for God."

Believer--why not?

Atheist: Because there can't be any such evidence.

Believer--how do you know that?

Atheist: because there aren't any


Beleiver--what about the stuff I just presented.

Atheist: I disproved that, it can't be evidence because there isn't any.



(1) Atheists selective rule out as 'fact' anything that doesn't match the ideology.

(2) Atheists reduce to a point of losing the phenomena any phenomena that stands against the ideology.

(3) Atheists use mockery and ridicule to shut down any discussion that is not in line with the ideology.

(4) Atheists exclude from reality any form of knowledge would give results contrary to the ideology.

(5) Atheists construct a false paradigm of knowledge based upon scientistic (not scientific but scientistic) assumptions.

(6) All thinking must be filtered through the ideology of atheistic sceintism.
__________________


Here's the rational, logical, factually oriented rebuttal of an atheist on CARM




NWRT- not worth responding to. And nothing you've written here changes that. I'll start taking you more seriously as an intellectual once you start addressing our actual arguments.


Go back and look over what you just wrote- now apply it to yourself. You do nothing but post ridiculous arguments (like your little "co-determinate" joke), insult people when they present legitimate disagreement, and present strawman versions of atheist's positions. Why on earth would anyone be interested in trying to have a genuine, serious discussion with you?


I asked him what's ridiculous about it:

I've explained it to you a million times- strong belief is not controlled for. And, true to form, you've only answered your strawman version of my argument.


Holy Irony Batman, doesn't this actually prove what I was saying? I have 300 studies he has 0. He decides this 'strong belief' which he can't define without a single study to back it up. Isn't this really a case of declaring my fact to be "no facts" because they differ form the ideology?

Monday, March 7, 2011

Atheits lying slander: How they Just Refuse to accept truth

the atheist pretender* who claims to have a degree in science.

Originally Posted by Mat Hunt View Post
Oh this is rich coming from you I must say!! Here is the man who invents concepts and then crowbars the notion of a deity into his arguments. Not just ANY deity though, the god of the bible.




I see you have learned to parrot back what you near these no knowing saying. Because they don't read theology and none of you has ever been to a seminary just by the general hatred you feel for Christians you assume you know more about it than someone who received Masters at a major seminary?

that's really brilliant. I know more than you do about scinece.

get it through your head little pretender. You don't know anything about ethology. you haven't read a single page. you can't name a theologian. you wouldn't have the sliest idea what you are talking about. I am spitting back the things I was tough in seminary by major theolgoians in the Methodist curacy how dare you try to tell me that you know more than I do? You don't know ****!

You would not know a single thing about theological concepts if one git you where you sit and gave you a head ache. you don't know **** from shinola about theology. have a Masters in it.

how dare you try to pass judgment on my views when you know nothing about the subject.


just more atheist gimmicky to dingoes ideas you can't understand or out argue. you can't deal with it becasue you don't know anything about so you just do a bunch of heckling like a kid on the play ground that's supposed to pass for "disproving it."

then you go "you are so insult." why the **** do think I am insulting! you are being grossly insluting. how dare you try to tell me I don't know my own field when you don't know it???

that's dishonest it's a con job it's a crime against reason its' slander I'm raise the bloody roof until they force you to stop slandering me.


*I did not call him a pretender to say question is degree. That is beside the point. In spite of his degree he is pretending to the commitment to scholarship and learning because he does not respect knowledge of any other aspect of he academy but his own.

Friday, March 4, 2011

Atheist "thinking"

look at all the ridiculously stupid things atheists say.

http://forums.carm.org/vbb/showthread.php?44007-Organizing-principles
Ironically the person who said this is called "Captain Obvious."
no 3 their great scholarly attitudes
I'm not gonna bother reading the whole thing...
but lemme guess.. "Anomaly! See? God exists!"


Originally Posted by Metacrock to electric skeptics View Post
no you haven't. you've making really petty picky silly little person jibes about me and one of you have answered of the major arguments of the op not one.
Electric skeptic in response to Meta

Why? All you'll do is claim "that's not addressing it!".
(that's becasue he hasn't actually discussed anything but how bad I am in several weeks)

Ben the Biased on CARM
to the cosmological argument:
Whoa, whoa! What "chain of dependent being we know?" I don't know of any such thing. I know of beings. I don't know that they form a chain, and I don't know that they're all dependent. Until this premise is established, the rest of the argument is irrelevant.
Originally Posted by catbarf (that's his screen name) View Post
Everything I have to say about the argument can be found several pages back, unaddressed by you. You have spent the intervening space on petty insults, ignoring criticism of your arguments or interpreting it as personal attacks.

Meta:
I answered it several pages back.
another Jim from Captain Obvious

Originally Posted by Metacrock View Post
you know you are just harping on words. Its' a perfectly fine term it's used in philosopher if you don't know that you don't know much do you?

you don't have an argument. until you can give me one you just underscoring the fac that I just proved God's existence.

CaptainObvious:Ya... this isn't about words! It's about feelings!
Originally Posted by kcdad View Post
The grounding issue is immature, that is, not fully developed. It is an issue for people who want semantics and not realities to be their source of meaning. Grounding axioms means to find the basis for them in a particular CULTURE and then suggest that it holds meaning across all cultural boundaries.

I don't completely under this guy, but I like his ideas.
http://www.philapologia.org/blog/201...-moral-truths/

I don't completely understand it duh, but it must be in my favor. What a classic! (read it, it's says he's wrong)



Originally Posted by Metacrock View Post
*Foundations of ethics: an anthology - Google Books Result
Russ Shafer-Landau, Terence Cuneo - 2007 - Philosophy - 504 pages
... the overall framework for moral theory that is a major concern of this essay. ... but builds them from one or another kind of supporting ground. ...
books.google.com/books?isbn=1405129514...

*singer
*good search:
The Ethics of Peter Singer - Vgweb Home Page
Given the importance of these axioms in the derivation of Singer's ethical rules they ... In S1 there are two major problems. Firstly there is the problem of ... Singer's concern of practical ethics means that he is not concerned with ... Even the very act of tilling the ground kills many earth-bound insect life, ...
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&s...=Google+Search
http://www.vgweb.org/manussa/Singer.htm

*

http://www.csufresno.edu/philosophy/...masCUPR1-2.pdf



*A Companion to Epistemology - Google Books Result
Jonathan Dancy, Ernest Sosa, Matthias Steup - 2009 - Philosophy - 799 pages
Here a major problem is to account for the grounding of memorial ... Social epistemology is also a major concern in my work, especially in my papers on ...
books.google.com/books?isbn=1405139005...


*Spinoza
The shape of deduction in Spinoza's "Ethics"
File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat - Quick View
One of the most remarkable features of the Ethics is its axiomatic form. ..... A major concern is that experiments based upon a selected subset of tests are ...
http://www.wischik.com/lu/philosophy...-deduction.pdf - Similar

http://www.wischik.com/lu/philosophy...-deduction.pdf

*


*Immanuel Kant
What makes them true a priori is that they have a cognitive ground which is not in ... His concern that he might actually die before finishing his work, ..... Kant did not see that the predicates of the axioms of geometry contained any ..... This produces something that is one of the major paradoxes of Cartesian ...
www.friesian.com/kant.htm - Cached - Similar

*spring link has article about the medical ethics and how ground for fundamental principles is going to become the major concern in the next decade.

http://www.springerlink.com/content/k2rq208567567866/
I don't see a single thing in any of those that speaks of grounding axioms. If you think there is something, could you quote it?



Ben the Biased:
I don't see a single thing in any of those that speaks of grounding axioms. If you think there is something, could you quote it?

Ben the Baised again:

Actually, I did some googling of my own, and I think I may have done your work for you. Check this out...

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/m...28663066/pg_7/

Lawrence Vogel. First time I've ever seen anyone anywhere other than you speak of "grounding axioms." It doesn't make any more sense when he talks about it than it does when you do, but at least now I have to admit you're not the only one in the entire world who's ever talked about it. He also talks about "being itself." I'm guessing he's a hero of yours.

In other words he doesn't know what he's looking for so when it sees it he doesn't nkow it. I had eight examples of ethics's saying this but becuase they didn't say "metarock is right about grounding axioms" he couldn't figure out it was the same thing.


This idiot who calls himself Kanascity Dad calis to be an athist and a methodist. He knows nothign about methodism. Perkins is one of the major Methoidst schools it's word famous for beign liberal. He decided it can't be liberal I went there and im' a liar and I'm so stupid and eivl I must be lying to it must be conservative and I'm too stupid to know the difference. Hes' the one, the one who thinks all MEthodsts are atheits knows better what makes one liberal and one conservative. So how doese he do it? He decides to prove Perkins is conservtive by lookat their website and taking the first gernal statment.

KCDAD
The opening statement on its website...

"God is leading you on a journey"
Is he really??? That is a very fundamentalist approach to searching for meaning in one's life.
"Whether your vocation is as pastor, educator, musician, youth leader, missionary, scholar, or committed layperson, the faculty and staff of Perkins will work with you to gather the resources—spiritual, intellectual and financial—that will enable you to answer your special calling."
Of course he's so ignorant he thinks belief in calling is really wild and radically fundie as though no liberals believing in things like having a calling. It doesn't even occur to him to look at the things they sya or what they teach or what their doctrines or, much less the fact that if he's a Methodist he should know about it.


Diest in response:

kcdad, a human being is what he thinks he is. If someone reads a book, like the bible, and believes what it is he reads, he will adopt those things he reads that resonate with him and his personality. This is why we have muslims flying planes into buidings. This is why we have nut cases saying we're going to burn in hell. We have a good amount of people who believe that they are called by "God" to do X. As we have seen, this calling can be someone like Hitler who some say he thought God wanted him to do what he did, or at the other end of the spectrum the nuns who help needy children. Or....it could be a Metacrock who thinks God has called him to spread his message. There have beenmany such people over the centuries who think they have a calling. That they BELIEVE they do is all it takes. there is nothing stronger than the power of a belief, nothing.

Originally Posted by Corsican View Post
You know what Meta, reading this thread actually kicked me into bothering to go to your blog. Having read most of it, I'm putting you on my ignore list. Your ideas seem reasonable a great deal of the time, your arguments are a great deal more coherent than many other folks over here, but you're just so downright ignorant and rude towards atheism that every time I read something you post, you just put me in a really bad mood. So sorry fella, I appreciate your effort and your arguments, but your attitude is so utterly appalling that I'm simply not going to put myself through reading your comments from now on.

this is a serious point. don't get hung up on thinking you have to answer insults to atheism before you understand what the point is.

Christian,

We're just playing with you guys. There is a part in each of us nonbelievers that gets a kick out of watching believers attempt to explain what they claim to be unexplainable and to try to use logic and reason for ideas that are based in faith. There is no other place one can find such exquisite irony, its almost as if its a parody
.

He's so brilliant:

Me: "all religious language is analogical."

Him: You are speaking analogically.

Me: I know I just said I am

Him: that proves you are stupid becuase I know that and you don't.

Me: I just said it

Him: it's such an irony that you can't see that

Me: I can see it I just said it

Him: I know, that proves your stupid. I'm just joking now. I'm not really saying you are really stupid, even thou obviously you are. but I'm not saying it except when I am.



We enjoy watching so-called apologist trot out their complexly named "arguments" such as the Transcendental Argument For God and the Cosmological Argument, there are several versions of the Ontological Argument etc and still be unable to demonstrate God in a practical, independently verifiable way, the way all other truths are demonstrated.

which you do not understand and you have no concept about.

Its interesting to watch the way a person who considers themselves to be quite rational be confronted with a logical contradiction in their own beliefs, one they have ignored or missed. Usually they immediately suspend reason and logic rather than consider their position might be flawed.

yet when I ask you guys to say what the contradiction is you can't do it. I say "Name the fallacy" you don't name one. I say "what's the contradiction" If you say anything (usually don't) then I explain why it's not one you never answer it. you just come back a week latter and say "we proved you have a contradiction" I guess you figure in a week everyone's forgotten.



I just want to apologize on the behalf of all nonbelievers (yes, I am taking quite a liberty here!) for presenting problems and questions to you for which you have no real answers.
I see one of his many areas of ignorance is the term Passive aggressive. It's mealy mouths wimpy and dishonest to say keep pretending that you not being insulting but in every signal instance between every line there's an obvious implication that the person you speaking must be an idiot if you what you say is true.

what a coward. he can't just come out and say "you are an idiot becasue XXX" he has to couch in this fake passive aggressive Bs. I'm not really saying you are stupid except when I say you are.

And also to thank you for providing so much entertainment.
BT
well Thank you for being an idiot. It's cute.

This is about as clever as 8th grade gets. I thought of little jazzy remarks like this thought them cleaver and insightful in 8th grade. Now it's so juninule for an adult to actually think he's begin original and witty in gains something that anyone can thin to say as a child.

where's the seriousl point? O don't have one.I just thought I would do the same thing he's doing.

Hey I'm just joking man! I am not really insulting you, just because you coward and *******. I am not really saying that. even though you are, but I'm just being funny.

I'm just funn'n ya, a buffoon like you surely can appreciate that.



In response to my argument that scinece is not the only from of knowledge:


OK, let's just believe anything.

Maybe "you" are really a chihuahua riding in the cockpit of a huge thought-controlled robot at the center of the moon, who remotely operates slave human bodies such as "Metacrock" to do its bidding.

Maybe the chihuahua controls all religious people.

You can't prove it isn't true, any more than I can prove that other minds exist.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Atheists too Cleaver for Their Own Good

Photobucket


here is my argument:

Organizing principles

PhysOrg.com) -- For a brief instant,
it appears, scientists at
Brook*haven National Laboratory on Long Island
recently discovered a law of nature had been broken.

Remember the argument asserts that law-like physics would be better explained if it were the product of a mind, since the universe has to come to be as result of physics, not as a means of creating physics. Therefore, since laws can't be disembodied things just floating about with nothing to describe or make happen there has to be some higher organizing principle that contains them and makes them work and a mind works best for that description. Even though the experiment at Brookhaven (see image link above) seems to imply that laws were broken the fact that laws are broken implies that they do exist.

Physorg.com
March 19, 2010 By Suzanne Taylor Muzzin


"Parity was long thought to be a fundamental law of nature. It essentially states that the universe is neither right- nor left-handed — that the laws of physics remain unchanged when expressed in inverted coordinates. In the early 1950s it was found that the so-called weak force, which is responsible for nuclear radioactivity, breaks the parity law. However, the strong force, which holds together subatomic particles, was thought to adhere to the law of parity, at least under normal circumstances.

Now this law appears to have been broken by a team of about a dozen particle physicists, including Jack Sandweiss, Yale's Donner Professor of Physics. Since 2000, Sandweiss has been smashing the nuclei of gold atoms together as part of the STAR experiment at RHIC, a 2.4-mile-circumference particle accelerator, to study the law of parity under the resulting extreme conditions."




Mat argues:

Mat Hunt, the laws of physics.
carm, 2/15/11
The "Laws of physics"(no 1 in thread)

I see this term thrown about with no regard to what it means and I thought I would do an OP to clarify what it really means. In order to to this I must first explain how things are done in physics. The first point to address is how do physicists find anything out in the first place and the answer to that is experimentation, this can be measuring something, seeing how something interacts with something else, a whole myriad of possible techniques.

Once the data has been gathered than the next task it to see what information can be obtained from the data, as well as if it possible possible to codify the data in the form of an equation, such equations are usually known as laws. The more experiments performed more laws are obtained and then the physicist can start incorporating the laws to make more general laws that explain more of the experimental onservation. These new more general laws will in general have the ability to predict the outcome of experiments that have yet to be performed and can be used to test the robustness of the laws themselves.

These general laws can sometimes be made into more general laws which can describe a whole range of phenomena, these more general laws are known as a theory in physics.

What most people refer to as the "laws of physics" are these sets of equations that have been discovered by physicists which describe (in the majority of cases to a very high degree of accuracy) what appears in nature.

It is not that nature appears to be inherently mathematical in nature but that it can be approximated by mathematical laws to an incredibly high degree.


HRG: responds to Hunt

Beg to differ on this point - slightly. IMHO the process is not so straightforward as you described it. Equations are not always just a mathematical summary of the data; often they are conjectured or extrapolated, and confirmed afterwards on the basis of their predictions.

I'm thinking particularly of three examples, which were jumps into the unknown, as it were.:

Maxwell's introduction of the "displacement current" (the time derivative of the electric field), confirmed afterwards by Hertz'


Meta:
Unfortunately for him this actually doesn't disprove my argument at all. He wants people to think it does because it says what I'm calling "laws of physics are not really laws." At the same time that has not the impact it seems to because it doesn't deny the fact that there are question about the law like regularity of the Universe behavior and they are not answering those questions. So what if the equations point to other things, those other things seem to require mind and they have no answer for this. In fact what that really does is confirm what I've sound about the nature of science it tears down the assertion of a fortress of facts and shows that it's actually more a matter of accepting a philosophy. There is no atheist fortress of fact with a moutin proved truths explaining everything in the universe. This scientist is actually admitting that. Of course the atheists on that board refused to see that. Then went on making like he really gave me what for.

Originally Posted by Mat Hunt View Post
As a working scientist I know this stuff very well. As other people have said you are confusing the "laws of physics" with nature itself, that is why your "fire in the equations" thread is very laughable, you confuse term and write in very vague terms without bothering to define them (I am thinking "organizational principle" here).


Meta:
This is a beef about protocol. If he controls the terminology then his view is in charge and the gaps are assumed filled by his ideology. He's merely complaining because my terminology is not his, but he doesn't actually explain the questions or say my view is wrong. I tired again to bridge the gap by discussing that we are both academics and as people of learning we should be able to communicate ideas not just put down each other disciplines. I kind of included him in the mix of intelligent people and he sort of canned the "this is laughable" and discussed it a bit more. Although I didn't convince him. I think see some flaws in his view. I'm sure he sees many in mine.


Originally Posted by Mat Hunt View Post
Not too sure what you're saying here. I was saying that your starting point IMHO was wrong. Causality is a consequence of other things.
When we become sloppy with our language, confusion occurs. You wouldn't want to convnce someone of god because of sloppy language would you?




Meta:

"sloppy" is relative. You define "efficient" in way that fits your social milieu in the academy--sort of akin climate of opinion. I do the same but in a different end of the academy. Also we are on a message board. When I speak like an academic on this board people complain about it.

The argument C/e is a consequence is is not necessarily an answer to my argument because I say "where are the laws before the universe exists." So become, that is coming to be would seem to require c/e yet what is this c/e a consequence of if there's nothing to produce a consequence? Presumably c/e must exist before the bb expansion right? Otherwise would make it expand?

I realize there's a problem with using the term "before." I have read that scientist get around this problem be speaking of "beyond event horizon." am I using that correctly?

Mat Hunt

I think you're talking about how the universe evolved from the big bang right? the way the physics unfolded? Wouldn't this just be a property of the universe like anything else? again an abuse of terms here could lead to problems


Meta:
Sure it would be once there's a universe. Where does the universe come from? What makes it be a universe if not physical or natural laws?

I see that part of the issue has to do with the way ideas are presented. The scientist wants a presentation that is under his control. It's really a problem of language. For example taking issue with the term "organizing princely." Not a term used in scinece so he assumes it's not good. Yet it describes perfectly exactly what the atheists, skeptics, and "forces of science" (which of cousre can't include believers in God) mean when they say "laws of physics are only descriptions. of the way the universe behaves." For example the evolution of sub atomic particles into stars and planets. The whole thing is the result of gravity. Gravity forms abstraction to the center of mass, larger and large units form so that particles become atomic particles and then molecules, molecules begin to exert a gravitational force and attract enough to form elements. Then we get gas and gas begin to exert a real force from its center of mass and forms into actual matter. Then it's just a matter of more attraction until planet formation happens. Once all that is accomplished then we start seeing a similar evolutionary build up form amino acids to life to organisms and on an on until we have cosmologists.

Obviously this could be described as an "organizing principle" as gravity clearly is a principle and has an organizing effect. This can masqaurade as a description only but there's clearly a covert reference to some regularity beneath the surface. One analogy used an atheist in that discussion, not scientific but not criticized by the scientist as such, even though my terminology was, a reference to "square peg in round hole." There's an organizing tendency in the shape of the hole. That would be a metaphor for the way this gravity thing works. The shape determines what fits in and what comes out. We can say that's descriptive of behavior but it's also an organizing principle, moreover, someone has to put a round shaped hole there and someone has to put a peg into it. In the final analysis they atheists and skeptics wind up making a bunch of meaningless statements every bit as unscientific and veg as the science guy says mine are; things like "it happens this way because it just does." One atheist summarized their position with the scientific terminology "a big pile of stuff that just happens."

Some atheists took umbrage over the metaphor of a law giver. In those discussions they insisted upon the image of law giver being litteral. I must have ment that in the most rigid sense, even though I died it the whole way through and continued to say "I don't literally mean a law giver in the sense of Moses with the tablets." I think the way I express argument best is done above here, "higher organizing principle" as the product of mind would be better than the notion of a big law giver. Of cousre God can be a principle, mind can be a principle. Anything within the range of Spinoza's ground of understanding, Tillich's ground of being, Hegel's dialectic, Berkeley's observer, or the transcendental signifier would work.

The atheists think they are really saying something when they assert a "pile of stuff just happens" all they are saying is "let's not think about it." No one in scinece ever says that. Atheists argue "can't you believers just assert the idea that things could just happen for no reason" but we never hear scientists say "we don't really theorize about the origin of the universe, things just happen, why worry it's just a pile of stuff." Far from being an answer to the argument it's nothing but a challenge to keep it going. I had originally possed it as a dilemma. They never eve responded to the other side. The other side being without prescriptive physical law, if the regularity of the universe that is so dependable is just discretion of "the pile of stuff that just happens" then there's real reason to rule out miracles, they are not violating anything. most people will admit that our descriptions can't be perfect so miracles just become the more compete description and there's really nothing bar them. They never really answer that. They just say "they don't happen." But of course that's just because they rule them out on the basis that they don't happen, but tha'ts a hold over form the Laplace who believed prescriptive laws of physics. Without real laws and no causality the atheist view point is a self defeating proposition.


here are the brilliant atheist answers on CARM:

"Captain Obvious:"

I'm not gonna bother reading the whole thing...
but lemme guess.. "Anomaly! See? God exists!"
that' so stupid and I'm so brilliant I don't even have to read it or say anything. How is that for stupidity? such a brilliant thinker he doesn't even have to know what you are arguing.

what about the great scientist Mat Hunt who "claims" of have "Ph.D" and be a "scientist." he's a scientist like I'm the king of England. Getting him to make an argument is like pulling eye teeth.

Once again you restate you flawed argument and you add some ad hominims into the mix.

Give a definition of organizing principle, not examples, a definition.
Once again I'm right, you are wrong don't need to talk about it. the stuff he said before ("once again") was just as terse and taciturn. He's not made a valid argument since he came onto the board.

Atheists just want to have their little world of anger and stupidity where they can bully Christians and fume hatred against God and not be reminded that they are wrong, that can't make good on their claims.



Originally Posted by maybrick View Post
One question, are ALL professional historians Christians?

The answer (in case you are wondering) is NO.


What does that do to your argument from authority?
Nothing. I know plenty of historians who are not Christians who agree that Jesus mythers are idiots and Jesus existed. My committee chairmen said to me "why do you argue ith idiots?" meaning the mythers. He was an atheist. but he knew better than to be a Jesus myther.

On a related note, are ALL biblical scholars Christian?

Nope again.

I didn't make an argument from authority. you are not dealing with the evidence you are using slogans and stereotypes and you lumping in the existence of Jesus with theology about his status. that's a very thoughtless mistake.

So, people who have far more expertise in this sort of issue than either you or I do not accept the Bible as true (in a Biblical/religous/true sense).



stereotypical thinking again. you assume anyone who has more expertise than I would have to disbelieve the bible. there are plenty of find charcoals who are among the best in the world who believe the bible. Of course you are assuming I'm a fundie and you are assuming an inferential. both assumptions are wrong. you are confused because you don't know theology so you don't know the divisions or breaks and you don't understand what liberals are.

I'm not claiming its worthless, or totally fabricated, or a cunning plan by the Illluminati to control millions of sheeple.


I didn't say you have to believer every word either.

I am merely using what I have learned from highly qualified, professional academics who have used "valid historical and scholarship methods" to come to the educated and reasonable conclusion that, while the Bible can truthfully be claimed to be many things...it is not the word of god.


I didn't even say it was the words of God. you are not even willing to listen. you assume a bunch of things about what I believe. this is what angers me that atheist have it down the point where it's just all or nothing. the bible is either a pile of **** don't even acknowledge it's existence it has nothing at all historically or it's totally true and you have to believe every word. Obviously both choices are stupid.

why don't you actually listen to what people say?


Then the inimitable "Big thinker" comes out with this gem:

Christian,

We're just playing with you guys. There is a part in each of us nonbelievers that gets a kick out of watching believers attempt to explain what they claim to be unexplainable and to try to use logic and reason for ideas that are based in faith. There is no other place one can find such exquisite irony, its almost as if its a parody.

so all the feelings of hurt and insult being slighted saying I'm lying about my life of learning that means more to me than anything spiting everything I value about myself that's all just a little joke.


We enjoy watching so-called apologist trot out their complexly named "arguments" such as the Transcendental Argument For God and the Cosmological Argument, there are several versions of the Ontological Argument etc and still be unable to demonstrate God in a practical, independently verifiable way, the way all other truths are demonstrated.


Its interesting to watch the way a person who considers themselves to be quite rational be confronted with a logical contradiction in their own beliefs, one they have ignored or missed. Usually they immediately suspend reason and logic rather than consider their position might be flawed.

I just want to apologize on the behalf of all nonbelievers (yes, I am taking quite a liberty here!) for presenting problems and questions to you for which you have no real answers.
And also to thank you for providing so much entertainment.
BT
that's' mighty big of you. you know people say I'm insulating them but it was a joke too, I was just paying along with you.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

The Athesit Arguments to disprove God:Atheist Straw man Version of God

Photobucket


Darth Pringle, CARM Feb 27,2011



This is an argument demonstrating that it is logically impossible for a necessary being to be a first cause of the universe even if it actually exists. It requires an understanding of possible world semantics (possible worlds are not all actual, but the actual world is a possible world) and Plantinga's Ontological Argument (see 5 below). That we speak of something existing in a possible world that is not actual can be potentially misleading.


1. A necessary being must be thought to exist in all possible worlds.
2. All contingencies can fail to be the case without contradiction (if all contingent things failed to exist tomorrow, it would not result in a contradiction).
3. Consequently, a world in which there is only a necessary being and no contingencies does not entail a contradiction (is a possible world).
4. A necessary being is not a first cause in a possible world where there are no contingencies.*
5. If a necessary being is not a first cause in some possible world then it is not a first cause in this (the actual) world.
6. Therefore, (from 3, 4 & 5) a necessary being is not the first cause of the universe even if such a being exists.


*Another way of supporting this premise would be to say that if God's creation of this (or any) universe is to be thought a choice then the possibility of him not creating anything must be thought to exist. Because the freedom for him being able to choose not to create anything is a logical possibility, there must be a possible world in which he never creates.




my answer:
Meta:

Argument invalid based upon 4 and 5. the function of 5 is to link the one possible to all of them. So the real problem is 4. The argument turns on the notion that you can have a possible world with no contingencies, just God. Then you say God can't be first cause in such a world, the you leap to the erroneous conclusion that therefore God wont be first cause in any world.

Invalid because it's only contingent on not creating. If God creates God is first cause. we have discussed this before. God's role as creator is contingent, that doesn't mean the divine essence is contingent. In Eastern Orthodox theology they distinguish between these two aspects saying one is God's energies and the other his essence. His energies include the acts God dose in being present in the immanent.

Things pertaining to divine energies can be contingent but not divine essence. The upshot for your argument is we need not think of God's possible limitation in a possible world as necessary for all possible words, because creatorhood is contingent upon god's energies in creating, but does not limit the divine essence from being necessary.

You are also creating a contradictory world and trying to feiot it in based upon the misunderstanding. While you can have a world with no contingencies and just God you can't have a world with God and bunch of contingencies he did not create. IF there a re contingents in a world God has to create them. That would make him first cause.


Originally Posted by Metacrock View Post
The argument turns on the notion that you can have a possible world with no contingencies, just God.


DP:
Exactly. Such is a possible world because God must be thought to exist in all possible worlds (if he exists) but contingencies do not have to be thought to exist in all possible worlds.

Meta:
Right but that doesn't change the fact that if any contingents come about they must be created by God (if there is a god) that means God must be first cause. First casue would be contingent upon creating but that is not an impediment upon God's necessity.

Then you say God can't be first cause in such a world
Of course. God can't be a first cause in a possible world where only he exists.

the you leap to the erronious conclusion that therefore God wont be first cause in any world.


DP:
Exactly. God is what he is in all possible worlds.
But he does not have to create in all possible worlds.

Meta:
Invalid because it's only contingent on not creating. If God creates God is first cause. we have discussed this before. God's role as creator is Continent, that doesn't mean the divine essence is contingent.

DP:
It means that a "creator God" is a contingent being because "creator" is contingent.

Meta:
you are not listening please read the words and think about what they mean:

(1) God is not a being.

(2) God's being is not contingent but his actions are (energies vs. essence).


You are also creating a contradictory world and tyring to feiot it in based upon the misunderstanding. While you can have a world with no contingencies and just God you can't have a world with God and bunch of contingencies he did not create.
You most certainly can.


DP:
There is nothing logically contradictory about the notion of things coming into existence acausally in a reality where God is thought to exist. You appear to be conflating between first cause and pre-condition.

Meta:
yes of closure there is, don't be silly! the concept itself is misguided and logically contradictory. The words are oxymorons "a causal" and 'creation" are opposite concepts. A creation is a cause.

that would be especially true if God is being itself.

the concept you have is quite wrong and this is the problem with making God into a being. God is not just one thing you can ad or subtract. If God is real then all being is in God. God has to be for anything to be. So there can't be contingencies that didn't make.



Confirmatoin of my argument comes from an atheist on CARM who is regarded as knowing a lot about modal logic:
Space Monkey

Interesting argument, but (if we ignore other objections here) I don't see why being a first cause could not be an accidental property of an otherwise necessary being, i.e. I would question (5).

This does raise issues concerning cross-world identity conditions, but these are not problems specific to the case of God.


DP goes on:

I think HRG's objection would be that a God who never creates cannot be the same being as one who does create. Therefore, if a being did create this universe, he cannot be necessary (exist in all possible worlds). Consequently, the only way that a necessary being could be necessary in this possible world, is if it doesn't create in any of them.

HRG has made the same mistake DP is making now many times. He tries to regard all of God's actions as necessary because God is necessary. He can't distinguish between energies and essence or in modern modern Western terms, "accidents" and essence. That's a major mistake because all the major philosophers have made that distinction. These atteampts doing trying to do what they think the Ontological argument is doing, only in reverse and disprove God (ultimately their aim is to "prove" that the OS is useless) are always turning upon some point that's misconceived and misunderstood. HRG's argument is wrong too. Notice how DP appeals to him as an authority when he's just another mistaken atheist.

Friday, February 25, 2011

Ad Absurdum: "Why I hate Atheists"

Photobucket


I ran into this amusing piece with a serious point I thought it deserved a read. It's a spoof so the title is not serious about hating atheists.

From the Blog "Ad Absurdum"

Ok, hate may be a strong word, but I do have serious problems with some atheists who think they are clever, or funny, by being so anti-religious. The following was posted to an atheist message board, with my responses following:

10. You hear any body say god you can't help but snicker.
9. The nearest bible is at that thing called church.
8. You think Pat Robertson and Jerry Fallwell should be put in an insane asylum and force fed prozac until they quit predicting doom and gloom all the time.
7. All churches should be taxed like any other business.
6. You know global warming is real like evolution.
5. Half your shirts have atheist or evolution sayings on them along with bumper stickers on your car.
4. Your library is mostly science, atheism and history.
3. You won't date a man or woman that if they believe in any of that holy shit.
2. You belong to an atheist organization.
1. You think the current president is some kind of devolved mutant variation gone horribly wrong.

10. Someone's belief, or disbelief in god shouldn't impact you one way or another. It's just another way to be smug and disrespectful.
9. Most people in the US have some kind of Christian upbringing, or at least exposure. It's childish to be so ignorant, so anti-religious that you wouldn't read a bible, koran, or torah. Being atheist should give you greater freedom to expose yourself to different religions. What are you afraid of, that the bible will bite you? Christians will tell atheists to read the bible, to look for the truth. I say, read the bible, and know it better then the person asking you to read the bible.
8. Robertson and Fallwell are crazy in their own right, but do you honestly think that someone else won't reach for the microphone when they are gone? There is a group of people who have this itch in the back of their mind, either through upbringing, social experience, or other times ignorance, which tells them gay sex is icky, or, Muslims sure are scary. Pat and Jerry do a good job of scratching that itch, it's a power trip that lots of people wouldn't pass up if given the chance.
7. Taxing churches is a tricky question. The idea is that churches don't provide any benefit to a community, and are actually profitable enterprises. The author may be thinking of mega churches with book stores and coffee shops inside. I do feel that a large enterprise like that should be heavily evaluated for tax exempt status. But what about the small churches in rural America who have enough trouble keeping members as it is. Not every pastor is driving a luxury car. It's difficult to separate the two, how do you determine who to tax? The thing I love most about churches is the ability to provide for a community, regardless of belief. I loved hearing stories about churches helping out during Katrina when no one else could. They didn't help to gain membership, or to be disciples, but to help people because they needed it. I'd like to see more of that. I think the homelessness problem could be helped over night if church doors were open all day and night. The hurdle is liability, and safety. I tell you if I had a church, I'd have it open as much as I could. I think there is a focus of large churches that resembles a business, complete with business plans, and marketing executives. But, how do you change that? Just like people aren't forced to give people on the street money, no one is forcing membership to mega churches.
6. I have no idea how the global warming issue became a religious matter, but again, I think there is a vocal minority who doubt global warming, and somehow think that by believing that the earth is getting warmer is a sign that god doesn't exist. That's a silly proposition. I think a lot of people are ignorant of global climate change, and maybe they were told something in church, so that's what they believe, but believers in global warming could also be guilty of the same fault, by taking an article or movie at face value. Here is my blip about global warming: We don't yet understand the human mind, or human physiology as well as we should. We have difficulty predicting weather past 30 days. We need to do much more serious work regarding global climate change. We just don't know enough yet. We don't know enough to determine which changes to make. Where should trees be planted, for example, to lower the temperature? We need a Manhattan Project for global warming. All of it may be for naught anyway, it may be a pattern in the cycle that the earth goes through. I do think that people are capable of coming up with solutions, we just need a lot of people, lots of solutions, and the ability to test them in simulation.
Read more, see link above.


Now let's look at the little mockers who come in to bash the eneny and stop the attack against their side.


Daniella said...

Wow, feel better now? For someone who is defending themselves against the 'ignorance of atheists,' you sure do know how to tip the odds in your favor. Not all atheists are intelligent and witty. Not all Christians are either. The fact is that this has nothing at all to do with religion (or lack there of.) It is on an individual basis that you determine arrogance or smugness.To say that you hate atheists, or even 'strongly dislike' them for being smug and arrogant, is rather blunt and inappropriate. I dislike small minded fundamentalists, but you don't see me taking quotes out of context and trying to prove that my point is more valid, and that the religious group I belong to is less arrogant and more intelligent. This is stupid. If atheists bother you that much, take it up with the individual that in particular is bothering you, don't rant and take it out on an entire group of people that have absolutely no ill intentions towards you. The only thing you will accomplish is breeding more hate and intolerance, BOTH ways.


So you can't say that mocking arrogant cretins are rude because it's their right to be rude? But she wouldn't hesitate to say all the standard mocking ridicule against Christians, then justify by saying 'but their is so stupid I don't have to read it." She's proving their point.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The on Going battle: Atheism is an organized objective but not a movement (?)!!

Photobucket



these comments were sent to me by Electric Skeptic a guy on CARM in response to "I am overwhelmed by their stupidity."

ES
Atheists aren't stupid - in fact, they are, on average, better educated and more intelligent than theists, and the claim that they "can't listen and don't think" is simply a lie.
Meta: First of all I was speaking of atheists on CARM, no all atheists everywhere. I wasn't counting people like Bertrand Russell in my remarks. I think there is a vast difference in people on message boards and in real life. The message boards draw a higher concentration of both stupid people and smart people. one can find very bright atheists on boards as well. The majority on CARM and other atheist boards such as Atheist net, are just childish.

btw on who is smarter, defining it by IQ (not necessarily the best) studies show 17 studies to 6 that religious people are either smarter or no correlation between belief and intelligence. The studies that show atheists are smarter are old and badly done. See my pages on Doxa.

ES
Atheism, of course, isn't a movement (a series of organized activities working toward an objective; also : an organized effort to promote or attain an end).
Meta: O really! that's interesting apparently I'm making head way. The peroper atheist template response is "atheism is merely the ab sense of belief in God or gods." To actually admit it's organized in any or has any connection to organized activities is a real come down form the standard response. Does anyone really think you can have a set of organized things seeking an objective (what is that objective?) without having a movement? Why do you mean "organized effort to promote or attain an end?" What end?

Isn't that rather like saying "I am not a thief I just liberate certain valuable objects from people who have a technical claim before the law to own them?" Come on, who is orgtanizing it? what end is working for (the destruction of religion?) Who organized it? What set the end or the objective? Why is that not the description of a movement? That's pretty transparent. What's intersting is that he didn't give the standard response. I think he sees that with the documentation I've used to prove therein an organized effort he realizes it's more ridiculous to try and claim there's no organized effort.

In any practical sense: it's a movement! (I get that he was defining movement not defining atheism I'm being factious, but he has not answered the proof the organized effort how could anyone deny that it is an organized effort with all those law suits and bus signs campaigns around the world it's obvious there's a huge amount of organized effort.).

ES
After your post about 8 levels of verification there were, of course, far more replies than "eye witnesses are bad. eye witness confirm Joseph Smith so therefore eye witnesses are bad". When you claim that saying that is "all that they do", you lie.
Meta:A few but not nearly "far more." Hardly.


ES
There is no "atheist summer camp" nor is there any set of standard atheist dogma, as seems to be implied.
Meta: I was real serious about summer camp. (aw rats, I was hoping for a good summer camp).


ES
And no, you haven't proved anything. You have provided some evidence; you have provided no proof whatsoever.
Meta: I've proved that belief in historical validity of the Gosples is rationally warranted. That largely is a matter of understanding the term "historical validity." Most CARMites assumed it means "the resurrection is totally proved." that would be a shallow claim. Obviously I never claimed that. Those guys never consider anything I say. We don't have to prove the truth claims of Christianty to establish the validity of religious bleief. All we need to prove is that it's rational to believe the truth claims. The valid existence of evidence justifying such a position is more than enough to demonstrate it's rationality.

ES
And as always you ignore the fact that most atheists quite readily agree that the evidence indicates that there was indeed a person named Jesus at the time and further, that he was a leader of some degree. It is the supernatural events described in the gospels that atheists reject as being unevidenced - quite rightly.
Meta: somehow those guys are always lost when the Jesus mythers start wailing on it. They never speak up unless you force them to.

ES
But of course, don't let the facts stop your endless tirade of hate against atheists.


Meta: Hey don't worry man, I wont. ;-)

thanks for your concern