Saturday, June 4, 2011

Atheist Replies on the "Courtier's Replay"

I got some hate mail about a thing on Meatacrock's blog which was published way back a year abo (June, 25, 2010) "what is the courtiers replay?" I thought it would be instructive to look at the comments form that time since there are some intelligent atheists making comment, such as my old friend Bap Gronk.


Derek Porter said...

You sicken me, you lying scumbag. Why must I waste my life sharing a planet with lousy shits like you? Because make no mistake, every second, every minute, every hour, every day, every week, every year, spent in the same universe as you IS wasted. And wasted through no fault of my own, but ENTIRELY through your fault. You loathsome piece of vomit.

O Yes they are not a hate group! they don't have an ideology? Who but a hate group ideologue would get so bent out of shape by the mere argument that one should know what one criticizes? This busienss of saying "Theology is stupid I don't need to know about it because I all I need to know is that belief in God is stupid" is just circular reasoning. It's the justification of ignorance.It's a refusal to think.

Brap Gronk said...

Part 1: Here is how I look at the Courtier’s Reply. Let’s go back in time to when the only part of today’s Bible that existed was the Pentateuch. (If that’s not the general consensus on which books were written first, feel free to substitute whatever book or books were written first in place of “Pentateuch.”) If a person of that era is presented with the Pentateuch and told it is the word of God, inspired by God, or whatever, that person can decide whether to believe it or not.

So, why would this person believe the Pentateuch is the word of God? One reason might be because this person already believes in one or more false gods who are allegedly responsible for various natural occurrences, so a story about a one true God, Lord of Lords, King of Kings, seems quite plausible. I hope we can agree that accepting the Pentateuch base on that line of reasoning is less than great, since it’s based on false beliefs. Another reason this person might believe the Pentateuch is the word of God is because he has been searching for answers to explain the natural world around him, and he thinks there must be a supreme being who is in charge of it all and created everything. In my opinion that line of reasoning is similar to the first reason, since those false gods were created for the same reason, to partially or wholly explain the natural world. It doesn’t seem much different than God of the Gaps, since at that time it was all gaps. (No need to shoot down God of the Gaps for me. I’ll remove that last sentence so we can move on.)

Are there any other reasons a person of that era might believe the Pentateuch is the word of God, based on the evidence available at the time? I don’t know.

On the other hand, why might our ancient person not believe the Pentateuch is the word of God? There could be any number of reasons to reject it, such as being generally skeptical of anything or anyone, having a dislike for authority, etc. These reasons are not based on any evaluation of the Pentateuch but are instead personality traits, so no need to consider those as being valid. But why might he reject the Pentateuch based on the available evidence? I can think of a few things he might say:

- This is just some oral history you people finally decided to write down. Why should I believe it came from a god?
- How convenient of you to write a story about how God has selected you as his chosen people and promised you some land. I wish I had thought of that first.
- This God character really cares about the minutiae of our lives, doesn’t he? There are so many rules in there that I’m more inclined to think this is an attempt to justify enforcement of your rules of behavior, not God’s rules.
- Your stories about God seem to stress rewards for those who obey him and nasty consequences for those who do not. Since I can’t verify this god of yours really did any of these nasty things to those who allegedly deserved it, this looks like a bunch of empty threats intended to make me fearful of not obeying your god.

These seem like reasonable objections to me, and I think it’s safe to say that if a group of people today came up with a story about how their god has selected them as his chosen people, promised them some land in rural Montana, and gave them a bunch of reasonable rules to live by, they wouldn’t be taken very seriously by anyone of any religious belief.

So I am suggesting we consider only the Pentateuch, and any theology based solely on the Pentateuch, when evaluating whether or not the Pentateuch was divinely inspired. Feel free to call it the Ancient Courtier’s Reply. If that’s considered unfair, keep in mind that that’s all our ancient person had to go on, too. No Jesus, no resurrection, no atonement. The Ancient Courtier cannot tell our ancient non-believer to wait because it will all make sense in a few hundred years after God sends his son to Earth.

Brap Gronk said...

Part 2 of 2: Another objection to the Pentateuch our ancient person would not have made, which we can make today, is based on the current level of scientific knowledge. Critics of the (Ancient) Courtier’s Reply will immediately say that if they can’t use the rest of the Bible and its theology to support the Pentateuch, atheists can’t use scientific knowledge that was not available at the time the Pentateuch was written. The difference, however, is that the scientific basis for rejecting the Pentateuch as being divinely inspired was true back when the Pentateuch was written, it just wasn’t known at the time. The remainder of the Bible, however, was not written until later, and many of the events certainly didn’t happen until later.

My position is this: An ancient person had no rational reason for believing the Pentateuch was divinely inspired, based on what we know today about the prevalent belief in false gods at that time. That’s a hurdle most Atheists can’t get over, which is why they say any theology about the rest of the Bible isn’t worth considering. The foundation is incredibly weak, and the ancient people who believed in this weak foundation built quite a large house on it. The Courtier keeps pointing out how wonderful the windows and doors are, and how beautiful the house looks from a distance. But the Atheists don’t care about the windows, the doors, or how it looks from across the street, because they have no faith in the foundation.

How does such a large, beautiful house get built on such a weak foundation? One contributing factor is groupthink. Once a group of people start believing in something, they tend to notice things which confirm their beliefs, and it’s difficult for a person in the group to stand up and say the beliefs of the group are wrong. The tale of the Emperor’s new clothes illustrates groupthink very well. Unfortunately, groupthink can go off in a really bad direction, and one need not look further than the crusades or the prosecution of witches to confirm that. If groupthink can go off in such a bad direction as the crusades, isn’t it plausible that groupthink could have gone off in an apparently good direction, building upon the weak foundation of the Pentateuch, adding more and more “goodness” to support that position, to the point where the Bible and theology exist today? Is it unreasonable to inspect the foundation with today’s knowledge? The rest of the house cannot support the foundation, no matter how well-constructed it is.

Metacrock said...

Because I think you should read things you criticize? that's such an unfair demand!

Metacrock said... from porter above:

You sicken me, you lying scumbag. Why must I waste my life sharing a planet with lousy shits like you? Because make no mistake, every second, every minute, every hour, every day, every week, every year, spent in the same universe as you IS wasted. And wasted through no fault of my own, but ENTIRELY through your fault. You loathsome piece of vomit.


I said people should try to understand things they criticize. why is that so terribly horrible? becasue you are filled with hate agaisnt religious people aren't you? why? because God wont let stick your dick where you want to sitck, right? so you hate me because I don't hate on your behalf.

you must be one of the most selfish idiot an puriel little cretins int he universe.

Metacrock said...

Brap Gronk
Meta to Brap
>>>No offense man but your ideas about how religion came to be and why people believe in it, why they believe sacred texts are totally out of date and have nothing to dow tih modern ideas about religion.

You are also acting like the whole of the Christian tradition is about the Bible, that's very old fashioned and silly and just plain wrong.

You also seem to be ignoring what the courtier's reply is about. It's basically saying "hate and ridicule things you don't know about." Or rather it says "religion is so stupid you don't have to learn about it or know what you say when you criticize it because it' just so dumb don't even bother thinking you might be wrong if you totally despise it.

That's so obviously ignorant. it's just nothing more than a lynch mob mentality.

This just really proves that atheism is a hate group.

Metacrock said...

for Brap Gronk part 2:

the foundation of religious belief is not holy writ, or a text. The bible is not the basis of Christianity. The basis of religious belief is the sense of the numinous. That is so well proved and so well documented in a practical sense it really proves the existence of God. It's so clearly proved that atheist have to destroy man's knowledge of it as I'm sure they will try to do.

they are already trying to ridicule the studies out of existence before they have read any.

Don't think I'm think that's anything against your intelligence or your knowledge. nO it's not your fault that think this way, how could anyone not think that way without special training in theology since the fudnies are the religious voice we hear in the media and the fundies worship the bible.

No way to get another impression unless you really study a broad field of philosophy religion, history of religions, mythology, psychology religion and theology. The only programs where you can get all that are in liberal seminaries.

Brap Gronk said...

"The basis of religious belief is the sense of the numinous. That is so well proved and so well documented in a practical sense it really proves the existence of God."

Does the sense of the numinous ever lead people to believe in false gods? Has it in the past? How does one tell the difference between a false god (one who does not exist) and one who practices divine hiddenness?

If we gathered a group of children who believed in Santa Claus, and over the years they compiled evidence of his existence, including their requests (prayers) to Santa Claus being answered on a semi-regular basis, how likely are we to believe in Santa Claus because of their sense of numinous?

I would agree that religions came about because of people believing in, or wanting to believe in, a supreme being, an afterlife, etc. I'm not suggesting the first Jew went around with a copy of the Pentateuch trying to convert people to Judaism. However, if the Bible is divinely inspired (inerrant or not), and the Pentateuch, as far as we know today, was the first part to be written, shouldn't there have been a rational reason for people to believe it was divinely inspired at the time? How else does a religion gain followers, other than by parents indoctrinating their children at a young age?

To move things forward a bit chronologically, would there have been a logical, rational reason for someone living in the first century BC to convert to Judaism if he was not raised as a Jew?

Metacrock said...

Does the sense of the numinous ever lead people to believe in false gods? Has it in the past? How does one tell the difference between a false god (one who does not exist) and one who practices divine hiddenness?



Meta: no it does not. Experience of God is beyond words and beyond understanding. All human verbiage about God is based upon loading that experience into cultural constructs. That's the only way to talk about them. In that sense they are all false even Christianity if you literalize the metaphors. If you understand that these constructs that gestures which point to a reality beyond themselves then it can't be false.

Jesus is the exception because he was not a cultural construct, but he still had to speak in cultural constructs to communicate with us.

Paul tells us God is working in all cultures, Acts 17:21-29. By what the Bible seems to say elsewhere we would normally think of the Greeks as evil, sataic, but Paul says the worshiped the true God, they just didn't know what to call him.

The false aspects come from literilzing the cultural constructs.

Metacrock said...

BGIf we gathered a group of children who believed in Santa Claus, and over the years they compiled evidence of his existence, including their requests (prayers) to Santa Claus being answered on a semi-regular basis, how likely are we to believe in Santa Claus because of their sense of numinous?


Meta:no one can bring back a dead father from realm beyond the styx by writing a letter to santa. no one can make an incurable patent live by the power of a letter to santa. Santa is given life by adults who think it's cute to keep the illusion going. But those adults cannot heal an incurable illness or raise form the dead to fool a child.

analogies are not proof.

I would agree that religions came about because of people believing in, or wanting to believe in, a supreme being, an afterlife, etc.

circular reasoning. why do they want that? You have to account for mystical consciousness and the sense of the numinous which is as old as the hills. The caveman Bulgarian give evidence of belief in after life, why? Because they sense the numinous, not because they had a preconceived notion of a God thousands of years before Humans talked about Gods.

We can trace the appearance of gods on the human stage of history, we cannot find the origins of the numinous which go all the way back to before we were human.

BG
I'm not suggesting the first Jew went around with a copy of the Pentateuch trying to convert people to Judaism. However, if the Bible is divinely inspired (inerrant or not), and the Pentateuch, as far as we know today, was the first part to be written, shouldn't there have been a rational reason for people to believe it was divinely inspired at the time? How else does a religion gain followers, other than by parents indoctrinating their children at a young age?


Meta no what I was trying to tell you before. you do not have an adequate understanding of how the Bible came to be or it's role in the Christian tradition.

I'm going to do a main blog post on this for next week.

Metacrock said...

BGTo move things forward a bit chronologically, would there have been a logical, rational reason for someone living in the first century BC to convert to Judaism if he was not raised as a Jew?

Meta You are trying to assume what the televangelists and fundies say is really Christianity. If you not in the club you are going to hell the only way for people to be saved before Jesus day was to become Jews. That is a false assumption.

People before Jesus' day did not have to become Jews to avoid hell. People in our day don't have to become Christians to avoid hell. Hell is just a metaphor for spiritual death and God is working in all cultures (Acts 17-21-29) and anyone who follows the moral law on the heart is following Jesus defacto (Romans 2:6-14) It's not a matter of everyone goes to hell but members of the club.

The reason to be in the tradition (the Christian tradition) is to know God, not to avoid hell.

Metacrock said...

After saying that a bunch of people are going to say "m a universalist." I am not a universalist. I am a liberal.

read my essay on Salvation and other faiths

Brap Gronk said...

Meta, is this part of your argument for the existence of God:

God exists because people have believed in, or sensed, his existence for as long as humans have existed. The best explanation for this sense of the numinous is that God exists.

Kristen said...

Derek, for Pete's sake! Where did all that hatred for someone you don't even know, come from? There must be some reason why this upsets you so much-- you're reaction is entiretly out of proportion to Metacrocks' post.

Brap Gronk, the reason you think the foundation is weak is that you don't understand the foundation. You might attempt to actually look at things outside your own box, before judging them from within your box.

The Courtier's Reply says, "Your ideas don't fit in my box and I'm not in the least bit interested in climbing out of my box. From in here I can't see what the fuss is all about-- therefore, you're making a fuss over nothing."

Metacrock said...

Brap Gronk said...

Meta, is this part of your argument for the existence of God:

God exists because people have believed in, or sensed, his existence for as long as humans have existed. The best explanation for this sense of the numinous is that God exists.

Not exact. without understanding how it's used it sounds stupid but let's consider how its used.

(1) how it's not used: that is not the turning point of the argument that proves the rationality of belief (don't forget I don't have to prove that God exists, my task is to prove that belief is rational).

(2) the turning point that prove rationailty is the outcome of having the experince.

(3)so how is this used: It's the link between the feeling (numinous, Utter dependence, peak experience or whatever) and its' identification with the divine. That doesn't prove God exists, it tells us why these experiences are associated with God.

It's just if I report that I saw a do do bird. you say "what makes you think the bird you say is a do do bird?" Because it fits the description. "how do you know the description is accurate?" Because this is the same description people have always given for the bird.

what would ever prove something? Your problem is you are so hung up on answerintg any proofs that you can't stop adn ask yourself what would be a rational reason to believe something?

don't fall back on the mistaken idea that belief in God requires big amazing miracles no one can deny that's an atheist straw man argument.

Brap Gronk said...

Kristen said: "the reason you think the foundation is weak is that you don't understand the foundation."

I realize that, which is why I am asking questions. I now understand the foundation of Christianity extends beyond (is earlier than) the Pentateuch.

If the foundation of Scientology is simply some of L. Ron Hubbard's writings, we don't need much Scientologist theology (if there is such a thing) to consider that a weak foundation. I suspect the apologists for Scientology have plenty to say beyond L. Ron Hubbard's writings, and when the Protestants, Muslims, Catholics and Mormons say it's a big fuss over nothing and don't bother to listen to it, the Scientologists might say those people don't understand the foundation and they are using the Courtier's Reply. (I doubt there is any comparison between the evidence presented to support Scientology and the evidence presented to support Christianity, so no equality is implied there.)

Brap Gronk said...

Meta wrote: "(don't forget I don't have to prove that God exists, my task is to prove that belief is rational)."

I'm all ears, waiting for some rationality.

"2) the turning point that prove rationailty is the outcome of having the experince."

Assuming you are not saying correlation proves causation, what are you saying there? I know some people feel better and have good things happen to them when they believe in God, and I think there are studies that have quantified some of those effects. But I think the most we can logically conclude from such studies is that belief in a supreme being has been beneficial for more individuals than nonbelief has been. I'm even ok saying "belief" is the cause of those effects if you want to go that far, but that does nothing to determine the validity of the belief. Once again, if children who believe in Santa Claus get more presents than those who don't believe in Santa Claus . . .

"(3)so how is this used: It's the link between the feeling (numinous, Utter dependence, peak experience or whatever) and its' identification with the divine. That doesn't prove God exists, it tells us why these experiences are associated with God."

Then I'll revise my guess regarding part of your argument for the existence of God. How's this:

The sense of the numinous that humans have had as long as (or almost as long as) humans have existed is universal. It is universal in the sense that it has similar characteristics across time, culture, geography, language, age, etc. The best explanation for this universality of the sense of the numinous throughout human history is the divine (God).

"what would ever prove something?"

Repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation seems like a good start.

"Your problem is you are so hung up on answerintg any proofs that you can't stop adn ask yourself what would be a rational reason to believe something?"

I'm not asking for a logical proof (deduction) of God's existence. Some inductive reasoning based on empirical evidence might be a good step toward rationality, though. Ignoring the ability of the human mind to convince itself something is true and to maintain that position, even when presented with overwhelming evidence (even video evidence) that contradicts it, seems a bit irrational.

"don't fall back on the mistaken idea that belief in God requires big amazing miracles no one can deny that's an atheist straw man argument."

I don't need a big amazing miracle to believe in God, although I cannot with certainty say what would convince me. But I can definitely state with certainty that without some convincing evidence of the supernatural interacting with the natural world, now or in the past, even a teeny tiny bit, I'm unlikely to consider it.

Some apologists like to say science cannot detect the supernatural, to which I say it can detect when things don't fit with our current knowledge of the natural world. If we consider the barrier between the natural and the supernatural to be a wall, science can detect where something goes through the wall and where it comes back. If it goes through and comes back in the same spot (divine hiddenness), I think it's more likely that it never crossed the wall at all.

Metacrock said...

I suspect the apologists for Scientology have plenty to say beyond L. Ron Hubbard's writings,

I wouldn't bet on it. We can distinguish between valid religions and cults and scams.

I have a friend who was into Scientology at one time. He says its' a cult and a scam.

surely a being from your advanced world understands that argument from analogy and guilt by association are fallacious right? So if one group is bad that doesn't' make all religious groups bad, right?

I'll answer your other comments at greater length tomorrow.

Metacrock said...

Meta wrote: "(don't forget I don't have to prove that God exists, my task is to prove that belief is rational)."

BG:
I'm all ears, waiting for some rationality.

Meta:
"2) the turning point that prove rationailty is the outcome of having the experince."

BG
Assuming you are not saying correlation proves causation, what are you saying there?


Meta: The rationality of belief is demonstrated by the effect of the experience of God's presence, or whatever you want to term religious experience. It's not an argument about causation because it's not a proof of God's existence, remember? all it has to show is that belief is rationally warranted. The rational warrant for belief is the effect of the experience.

BG
I know some people feel better and have good things happen to them when they believe in God, and I think there are studies that have quantified some of those effects. But I think the most we can logically conclude from such studies is that belief in a supreme being has been beneficial for more individuals than nonbelief has been.

Meta: wrong!

(1) don't reduce the effects with faint words like "feel better." These clinical and scientific analysis demonstrating dramatic and transfomrative effects.

(2) you can't argue that belief makes you feel better because these are dramatic experiences of sort that involve raising the level of consciousness through sensation of a presence and unity in the world that indicates the awareness of the divine. These experiences are not beliefs that make you feel better,they are often the reason one begins to believe. Not just feeling better but total life transformation.


read this link on the effects

this one states the argument in a somewhat more formal way and offers more evidence.

BG
I'm even ok saying "belief" is the cause of those effects if you want to go that far,

Meta: disproved by the fact that for many the experience is the cause of the belief not vice verse

BG
but that does nothing to determine the validity of the belief. Once again, if children who believe in Santa Claus get more presents than those who don't believe in Santa Claus . . .

Meta:children don't experience the presence of Santa.

you are arguing from analogy and your analogy is a bad one becasue it doesn't apply. Sensing the numinous or hte presence of God is very different from being told you parents about santa, totally different things.

I'll put up a major blog article on this soon, but first I want to deal some other things you raised.

I'll deal with the rest of your comments tomorrow.

you can come to my message boards too you know for more extended discussion.


doxa forums

Metacrock said...

"(3)so how is this used: It's the link between the feeling (numinous, Utter dependence, peak experience or whatever) and its' identification with the divine. That doesn't prove God exists, it tells us why these experiences are associated with God."

BG
Then I'll revise my guess regarding part of your argument for the existence of God. How's this:

The sense of the numinous that humans have had as long as (or almost as long as) humans have existed is universal. It is universal in the sense that it has similar characteristics across time, culture, geography, language, age, etc. The best explanation for this universality of the sense of the numinous throughout human history is the divine (God).

meta: that's good. It's a rational warrant for belief becasue it' the best explanation for it.

"what would ever prove something?"

BG
Repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation seems like a good start.

the M scale provides that. Since it was verified through over a dozen studies in about that many cultures. The M scale is a means of determining one has had a valid mystical experience. For this reason it's also the best way to make a definition of what that is. It's validated because the numbers bear out the theories of W.T. Stace who drew up his theories from the writings of the world's major mystics. So the mystic's experiences are verified in that their experiences are echoed in the experiences of people around the world.

Meta"Your problem is you are so hung up on answerintg any proofs that you can't stop adn ask yourself what would be a rational reason to believe something?"

BG
I'm not asking for a logical proof (deduction) of God's existence. Some inductive reasoning based on empirical evidence might be a good step toward rationality, though.

Meta ok fair enough I think I just provided that.

Metacrock said...

BGIgnoring the ability of the human mind to convince itself something is true and to maintain that position, even when presented with overwhelming evidence (even video evidence) that contradicts it, seems a bit irrational.

say BG you keep putting the cart before the horse. For a lot of these guys the experience came first, so the experience is not being determined by the belief but the belief by the experience.

that's how it was for me btw.


Meta"don't fall back on the mistaken idea that belief in God requires big amazing miracles no one can deny that's an atheist straw man argument."

BG
I don't need a big amazing miracle to believe in God, although I cannot with certainty say what would convince me. But I can definitely state with certainty that without some convincing evidence of the supernatural interacting with the natural world, now or in the past, even a teeny tiny bit, I'm unlikely to consider it.

why do you say that? where do you get the concept of a Super natural?? why would you associate it with God?

here's an article I did some time ago (2006) what is the supernatural?

GB
Some apologists like to say science cannot detect the supernatural, to which I say it can detect when things don't fit with our current knowledge of the natural world. If we consider the barrier between the natural and the supernatural to be a wall, science can detect where something goes through the wall and where it comes back. If it goes through and comes back in the same spot (divine hiddenness), I think it's more likely that it never crossed the wall at all.

meta please read the link I think you will see you have the wrong end of the stick. the concept of supernatural is not understand by atheist, or aliens from other planets, nor most Christians for that matter.

that article will tell you what the super natural is. this one shows you empirical evidence of the SN

Kristen said...

Brap Gronk said:

"Repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation seems like a good start."

Metacrock spoke of the M-scale as a verifer of religious experience. But I suspect that won't be good enough for you because your words above show that you're stuck in your box. You can't prove someone loves you through "repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation." You can't understand a piece of artwork, or a poem, through "repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation." You can't even prove you exist through "repeatable, predictable, observable, verifiable results of experimentation."

If your only tool is a hammer, everything is going to look like a nail. Science is your hammer. Lay it down for a minute and see that there are things in the world that have nothing to do with being nails.

Metacrock said...

If your only tool is a hammer, everything is going to look like a nail. Science is your hammer. Lay it down for a minute and see that there are things in the world that have nothing to do with being nails.

that's good. I like that. You are right Kristen. We don't have to replicable scientific standards to know phenomenologically verifiable apprehensions.

The M scale does mean that testing the validity of RE fits the criteria he laid out for scientific verification. But it doesn't have to be there for every aspect of belief. It works for verification of that experience, it doesn't have to available for verification of God's existence.

God is not a scientific question. So we can have the scientific criteria for things that fit scientific questions and we can have experience for God.

Brap Gronk said...

Thanks for the dialog and the links, Meta. I see there's a new posting on your blog I might be interested in, too. I have a bit of reading to do, and unlike Mr. Porter I enjoy reading viewpoints from the other side, so I'll probably lay low for awhile. But to borrow a line from the Governator: "I'll be bach."

Metacrock said...

Thanks for the dialog and the links, Meta. I see there's a new posting on your blog I might be interested in, too. I have a bit of reading to do, and unlike Mr. Porter I enjoy reading viewpoints from the other side, so I'll probably lay low for awhile. But to borrow a line from the Governator: "I'll be bach."

OK Brap, thanks. you are always welcome. Don't forget my message board.

I'm going to respond to of your comments in the main section so keep a look out for that.

Friday, May 27, 2011

Predictions that Religion Will Become Extinct in Some Countires

Photobucket



Religion May Become Extinct in Nine Nations



The study is done by the American Physical Society, an organization of physicists. why would they be studying religion? Perhaps its to analyze their statitsical model which enables one to analyze things with a huge data base:

Their means of analysing the data invokes what is known as nonlinear dynamics - a mathematical approach that has been used to explain a wide range of physical phenomena in which a number of factors play a part.

One of the team, Daniel Abrams of Northwestern University, put forth a similar model in 2003 to put a numerical basis behind the decline of lesser-spoken world languages.

That would explain their interest in the topic, but it still doesn't' guarantee results. What are the nations in question:

The team took census data stretching back as far as a century from countries in which the census queried religious affiliation: Australia, Austria, Canada, the Czech Republic, Finland, Ireland, the Netherlands, New Zealand and Switzerland.

The assumption is that there is a utility or a status in taking part in some socially advantageous activity rather than one that is not as useful or that doesn't garner enough status. There's more utility in speaking Spanish in Peru rather than a dying Native language.

"For example in languages, there can be greater utility or status in speaking Spanish instead of [the dying language] Quechuan in Peru, and similarly there's some kind of status or utility in being a member of a religion or not."
Dr Wiener continued: "In a large number of modern secular democracies, there's been a trend that folk are identifying themselves as non-affiliated with religion; in the Netherlands the number was 40%, and the highest we saw was in the Czech Republic, where the number was 60%."
My friend Tiny Thinker, who is a professional anthropologist and runs the Peaceful Turmoil Blog has discussed this study and shows the fallacies and flaws. His take on it I urge the reader to consult and take seroiusly. Tiny is one of the most brilliant people I've known.

But here are my ramblings on the subject:


There's always a conceptual flaw in every study. We find that while they do documented through a study at Cornell that the social dynamics of the countries named are similar to each other, that does NOT prove that they are similar to the societies where the dying language dynamic is studied. Declining religion and declining religion may be two different things. This reality is reflected in statements by the researchers themselves:

However, Dr Wiener told the conference that the team was working to update the model with a "network structure" more representative of the one at work in the world.

"Obviously we don't really believe this is the network structure of a modern society, where each person is influenced equally by all the other people in society," he said.

However, he told BBC News that he thought it was "a suggestive result".

In other words people in modern industrial societies are more indpdent and less dependent upon immediate traditional support than natives in South America. So the stakes of belief in religion in modern industrialized West are different than those of speaking a language in a third world country. There are a lot of other things they are not taking into account too.

First of all they need to prove that the non affiliated status is really equal to "non religious" status. All they are really saying is that they equate belief with membership. That is a false assumption. The most this study can prove is that the lines of affiliation are shifting, it doesn't and can't demonstrate that actual belief in God will go extinct in these nine countries. The most it shows is that traditional churches may fail.

There is a very useful study we need to know about, that tells us some things germiane to this issue: The Demand for Religion:Hard Core Atheism and "Supply Side" Theory by Wolfgang Jagodzinski, University of Cologne, Andrew Greeley,University of Chicago and University of Arizona.

This study shows that Northern Europe is still more religious than social scientists have given it credit or. It's true objective is to disprove the theory of supply side economics as applied to religious believe, but in executing that goal there is some data would should interest us. At this point I'll refer to this new study as "Greeley." I'll refer to the original study as the APS study.

Norway is not as religious a country as Ireland (many of whose citizens are distant relatives of the Norse). However, religion persists in Norway. Moreover, the recent research on the social history of religion in the middle ages raises serious questions about how religious any country in Europe was in ages past. Perhaps Norwegians are less devout than they used to be, but that fact remains to be proven. Hence it remains to be proven that there is not a religious demand in Norway to which the religious supply has failed to respond.
That is interesting because Norway, being Scandinavian, is supposed to be totally secular and religion on the way out. It's not as religouis as Ireland, Ireleand is ond the countries in the APS study. That means Norway should be almost bereft of religion by now but Greeley names the section on Norway "the failure of secularism" and says it's, though not as religious as Ireland still plenty religious. That would seem to suggest that religion is in even better shape in the more religious Ireland.

Greeley:

The religious picture of Norway which appears in these three tables indicates that the portrait of the country as being in the final stages of a secularization process is, to say the least, much too simple. Even the "social differentiation" dimension of the secularization theory is hardly compatible with the financial contributions all groups make to church organizations. Religion has not disappeared from the public or private lives of Norwegians. There are traces of religion to be found among both the Atheists and Agnostics and strong residues of religion among the Marginals. The differentiation between the Devout and the Private is what one might expect in a society where there is a lazy monopoly and no great effort to reclaim to the Private to say nothing of the Marginal.

Are the Norwegians religious? Thirty seven percent of them say they are, while only 16% say that they are not; the rest equivocate by saying that they are neither religious nor non-religious. Seventeen percent of the Marginal and 53% of the private assert that they are religious. To assert that such a country is thoroughly secularized is to deprive the word of all meaning.


here is what Greeley says about Ireland:

Unfortunately for the efforts of those to apply the "supply side" perspective in Europe, there are few countries in which an open religious market place exists. Germany is a duopoly, the Netherlands a collapsing triopoly. However, Ireland is an excellent natural laboratory for testing the perspective. Ireland (the twenty six counties in the South) is a de facto Catholic monopoly while northern Ireland is a fiercely competitive market place in which Protestants and Catholics compete, not infrequently inn the streets. While both Catholics and Protestants in Ireland are devout, the supply side theory would predict that Catholics in the North would be more devout and more orthodox than Catholics in the South.

In fact the data in Table 9 do not force us to reject this hypothesis derived from supply side theory. Northern Catholics are notably more likely to be believe in God, the Devil, life after death, heaven and hell. They are also more likely to attend mass regularly and to reject extramarital sex and homosexual behavior. It seems probable that in the absence of competition on the southern counties, Catholicism has lost something of the "edge" it once had in both orthodoxy and devotion while in the competitive northern counties, the orthodoxy and devotional levels have been only slightly affected, if at all.

Doesn't really seem like a place where religion is dying out. Over all they find that Northern Europe is still very religious and atheism is very soft core. Hard core defined as answering "I do not believe in God" and "there is definitely no after life." the questions:

  1. I don’t believe in God
  2. I don’t know whether there is a God and I don’t believe there is any way to find out.
  3. I don’t believe in a personal God, but I do believe in a higher Power of some kind.
  4. find myself believing in God some of the time but not at others.
  5. While I have doubts, I feel that I do believe in God.
  6. I know God really exists and I have no doubt about it.

And

Do You believe in life after death?

  1. Yes, definitely
  2. Yes, probably
  3. No, probably not
  4. No, definitely not

Soft care atheists defined as rejecting God but not after life.



  1. The proportion of Hard Core atheists is relatively small in all the countries except East Germany (42.7%)
  2. The proportion is above 10% only in former socialist countries (12.4% in Russia, 13.9% in Slovenia, and 11.3% in Hungary) and in the Netherlands (11.4%) and in Israel (12.1%).
  3. In the other eleven countries, the highest rates of Hard Core atheism are in Norway (6.7%) and Britain (6.3%). Thus if latent demand for religion is excluded only from the Hard Core atheists, there is still the possibility of a large clientele for those firms which might venture into the religious market place in such supposedly "secularized" countries as Norway and Britain.
  4. There are not all that many Hard Core atheists in the countries studied, nor indeed all that many soft core atheists either.
  5. The "Softest Core" Atheists are less than a third of the population in every country except East Germany. They are more than a fifth of the population only in four former Socialist countries – East German Russia, Hungary and Slovenia. With the exception than of East Germany more than two thirds of the population of the countries studied are willing to admit the existence in some fashion of God and the likelihood of life after death. Devout many of them may not be but on the two central issues they are more religious than not. They then may be considered as part of the religious market place if not always enthusiastic consumers.

Furthermore in the sample as a whole, Hard Core atheism correlates only with gender (women less likely to be atheists) and not with education or age (those favorite measures of the more naïve of the "secularization theorists.") 83% of the Hard Core Atheists say they never believed in God, 61% say they never attended church services when they were eleven or twelve years old and 9% more say they only rarely attended. The choice of Hard Core atheism as a philosophy of life was apparently made at a very young age in life and is sustained through the life course.

Age correlates significantly with Hard Core atheism only in Britain (r=-.08), East Germany (r=-.18), the Netherlands (r=-.05) and Israel (r=+.08), Hungary (-.14). Education correlates significantly with Hard Core Atheism only in Hungary (r=.11), Slovenia (r=.18), and Norway (r=.10) West Germany (r=.08), Israel (r=.10). In these countries as in the whole sample, there is an inverted U curve in the relationship between age and atheism, the very young and the very old being somewhat less likely to be atheists. In the middle years of life, however, the line representing atheism is flat. Only in Slovenia and Hungary is education still a significant correlate of Hard Core Atheism in a regression equation which includes age and gender.

In the United States, Northern Ireland, Austria and Poland, the countries with the lowest scores for atheism, there is no correlation with gender.

Table 2 demonstrates that Hard Core atheists in the countries where they are most numerous have been for the most part atheists since childhood. Everywhere but Great Britain, West Germany, and Norway, four out of five assert that they never believed in God. Only in Britain did the majority say that they went to church more than rarely. In East Germany, Norway, the Netherlands, and Russia more than seven out of ten went to church only on rare occasions.



That includes two of the counters in the APS study. This certainly should give us pause to consider the fallacies of that study. The sense of religion fading away is strongest in the Scandinavian countries. We have seen that Norway is still religious, now we find that Sweden is as well.


Sep 1, 2006
Are Swedes losing their religion?
by: Charlotte Celsing, freelance writer


Annika Gustafsson is a theology student whose studies have included work experience in congregations and at confirmation camps. She says that almost all of the young people she meets are open to questions relating to religious and spiritual matters, even though they may have objections to ecclesiastical matters.

The role of religion has changed

Religion has not become less important in Swedish society but it has changed color, according to a report from Ã…bo Academy (Finland). In the secularized Nordic area the Protestant Lutheran church has to be liberal and open to a modern interpretation of the Christian message. Otherwise the church feels too authoritarian – an attitude that most Swedes do not accept....Yet many Swedes express a longing for a spiritual dimension and a deeper meaning. Modern society has left a void that neither science nor a high material standard can fill....Those who the Church of Sweden fails to attract look for alternatives. Non-conformist churches – of which the Pentecostal Movement is the largest with around 87,000 members – is one example. Others are varieties of eastern religions, such as Buddhism or Hinduism.


Due to immigration to Sweden, Islam is now the country’s second largest religion after Christianity. A number of mosques have already been built in different parts of Sweden and more are planned.


Within Christianity the Catholic Church in Sweden is also large. Today it has a total of 80,500 registered members.

* Almost 8 out of 10 Swedes are members of the Church of Sweden - 7 million.
* Only 1 in 10 Swedes thinks religion is important in daily life.
* Around 7 out of 10 children are christened in the Church of Sweden.
* Just over 5 out of 10 weddings take place in church.
* Almost 9 out of 10 Swedes have Christian burials.
* Islam has around 130,000 adherents in Sweden (more according to Muslim
sources).(Ibid)

If the countries of Northern Europe are holding on to faith in many aspects, though the standard image is that its all but gone, the findings pertaining to more religous countries like Ireland are probalby wrong.


On CARM an atheist used this study to argue that all religions going to die out. This is another example of the stupidity of atheists, their dishonesty and their inability to understand what they read. He extrapolates form nine nations to all of it dying out becuase that's what he hopes for. So typical of the to ignore the details.

Atheist Use of Black is White Slide

Photobucket


Here's a bad habit I see atheists doing a lot. I don't want to point out who did this because I don't want that person to think I'm just trying to insult him, but it someone on this baord today who did this.

I go "you can't say X,Y,Z about Christianity belief because you missing whatever, historical tradition, theological stuff, ect.

He goes I don't need to read that because I know that Mormonism is stupid and I don't need to read about it. so therefore, this other thing I don't about must be stupid too so I don't need to read about it either.


The reason why one needs to know theology before criticizing religion is not necessary to know what evdience supports it's truth but just to know if the statements being made really reflect the belief of the tradition.

One example I think of is this really stupid guy I was arguing with on his blog. He said that "Christians believe that God is a big man in the sky." I said no not all Christians believe that, I named a few theological tendencies that got passed that like Tillich and process theology. He goes "You are a liar! they do do that's just a lie." I said if you knew theology you would know how wrong you are. So he asserts "I don't have to know theology because its' stupid to believe in God so nothing in theology is worth crap."

the point is he's wrong about what he said about all Christians believing God is a big man in the sky, if he knew theology,even if they still thought it was carp, he would at least know that process theology is famous for noting thing of God as a man. they don't even think god is personal.

Instead he says "that can't be true, just don't' confuse me with the facts!"

in the first example that's just guilt by association.

[B](1) I can know Mormonism is stupid without knowing what it says" [/B]that's just dumb. that's like saying I judge a book by its cover.

All of these things are the result of the decline in education since the Regan era.

(2) the to assume If I know X is stupid without knowing what it says I can know that more orthodox forms of Christianity are stupid too with knowing what they say because of some similarity that I find bewteen the two: that is actually two fallacies in one.

(a) it's guilt by association

(b) also the black is white slide.

black is white slide says "two things that totally dissimilar are the same thing because they share one point in common."

All based upon the fallacious idea that "don't confuse me with the facts," I can know stuff without knowing about it.

that's just anti-intellectual drivel.

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Stupid Atheist Tricks no. 5,207

This CARM genius calling himself MFFJM2

Just about one of the stupiest people I've ever seen:

set up. thread title: Theists and Intelligent life on Other Planets

Pay off:


Originally Posted by Metacrock View Post
If they find intelligent life on another planet it would be a great shock. We have never found any on this planet.
The genius observes:

MFFJM2

Should the deeply held beliefs of creationists be shattered by events such as you describe, which would be too obvious to contradict or ignore, they would either convert to some other lesser known cult, or they'd kill themselves en masse. This is why you get remarks like that of Metacrock or Kent Hovind, because in the event that your hypothesis should prove true, everything they believe in would come crashing down around them. The cognitive dissonance would be too much.

I respond
Meta:



you think I'm a creationist when I talk about Paul Tillich and God is being itself and process theology. That's about as intelligent as saying that Obama is in the tea party or that the Tea party is for socialism.

In fact that is literally the case. Tillich was a socialist and most creationists are right wing and probalby close to tea party. So what you are saying is as knowledgeable as calling Obama a tea party guy.
MFFJM2


You're no liberal. You used the exact same words as Kent Hovinnd, whether you knew it or not. The remark you made was meant to dismiss the OP. It didn't work.
I didn't write that you were a creationist, possibly a problem with your reading ability. I wrote directly to the remarks that you echoed from Kent Hovind. The fact that you have mentioned Paul Tillich doesn't change the fact that you have responded on numerous occasions with fundamentalist remarks. If you don't want to be painted as a fundamentalist, perhaps you shouldn't stand so close to those who are.
Meta:

that is so stupid! only someone with a really limited cultural knowledge would say that. that is an obvious joke that is based upon a Lilly Tomlin line. It's not an ideological position and it can't be thought of as any kind of proof that one is a liberal or a conservative. So Hovind and I both have heard of Tomlin, big deal.

that is the kind of cultural illiteracy that marks kids born in and after the Regan era.

First of all it's stupid to say that "I didn't say you were a creationist" you are only accusing me of being like a rampant creationist who is notorious for his creationism so obviously that the implication. Secondly you don't know what liberalism is and you wouldn't know a liberal from a conservative if the difference bit you in the ***
Accusing someone of saying something "like what they would say" is guilt by association.

Fortunate there some smart atheists around.
Bust Nack says:
I think you are reading too much into a joke from Meta.
What can one say?

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Atheist Confirmation bias in action

Photobucket


on CARM

They assert that documents were destroyed in the canonizing process. I ask for documentation they give only conjecture (it must have hapepned because Christians are evil and mean). I say that is only conjecture.



Originally Posted by Metacrock View Post
your argument is one form conjecture and prejudice. you have no historical evidence to back it up. If it has happened there would be someone somewhere in that era writing about it.



cottreau
Well, no - there are lots of historical events that go completely unrecorded and I'm sure there were lots of documents destroyed by the church where no one has recorded the event.
However, you are right - there is no historical evidence that we know of. While people want to believe it, since it seems that the church at the time was fully capable of such atrocities to history, wanting to believe it doesn't make it true.
conjecture!



He did actually assert that the historical (he means naturalistic) parts of John might have history in them. KCD says "prove it." he says:



Originally Posted by cottreau View Post
I'm just quoting Robin Lane Fox, a Greek speaking/writing, Oxford classics scholar from the same book I mentioned in the last post ("The Unauthorized Version: Truth and Fiction in the Bible"). Fox is an atheist as well, so I consider it meaningful.

2nd party is us, the reader (with any document, the 1st party is the writer, 2nd party is the reader). 3rd parties would be Roman and Jewish texts from the time. "factual" about neutral historical events and procedures, the number of pillars in a specific building, how people were crucified and buried, wrapped in a shroud and various other trivial facts. They are all correct in John, but vary in the other gospels according to Fox.

Fox can't speak to the miracles of course, but as a historical, eye witness document, John is the best of the 4 gospels.
That proves your confirmation bias right here. you are so biased you automatically discount any evidence except from an atheist. that is brain washing. because you wont get anything form an atheist but atheism.

all you are saying is 'I refuse to consider the fact, just confirm want I want to believe." He says he considers it meaningful because he's an atheist, that means he doesn't consider it meaningful if it's by a Christian or some kind of believer.

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Athiest Propaganda on Deafault Assumption

Photobucket
Austin Cline

On Metacrock's Blog I have demonstrated certain studies show that religion is innate. The evdience is pretty strong for an innate religious sense. This blows away the use of the "default" that atheists try to employ,the mistaken notion that we "are all born atheists." Let's look at some illogical to uses atheists make of this assumption.


Austin Cline on Atheist Default



Do infants and very young children qualify as atheists? Most atheists will say so, working from the definition of atheism as “lacking belief in gods.” Theists tend to reject this definition, even if they don’t use the narrow definition of atheism as “denial of gods.” Why? If infants lack belief in the existence of gods, they can’t be theists - so why not atheists?
The evidence is huge that religious instinct is innate. Religion is not something that has to be trained into a child. The particular tradition and doctrines do but not the basic concept.

He goes on to quote:

In Atheism: The Case Against God, George Smith writes:

Upon close examination, it is likely that the objections to calling the uninformed child an atheist will stem from the assumption that atheism entails some degree of moral degeneracy. How dare I call innocent children atheists! Surely it is unfair to degrade them in this manner.

If the religionist is bothered by the moral implications of calling the uninformed child an atheist, the fault lies with these moral implications, not with the definition of atheism. Recognizing this child as an atheist is a major step in removing the moral stigma attached to atheism, because it forces the theist to either abandon his stereotypes of atheism or to extend them where they are patently absurd.
This is sheer lunacy. Not only are kids bron with innate senes of God or some "higher power" but they are not cognitively developed to the extent that they can actually doubt anything. They are no fits judges of God' existence either way. Calling them atheist is calling them communists. Can you say a baby is born a communist? That woudl be unethical if one labeled an infant with some tag phrase an opposition political group, or even his own. This is such obviously totalitarian thinking.

Yes here we have the dirty little secret guys like Cline want to keep under wraps, their movement is totalitarian.


several erroneous ideas on yahoo answers

These things are so silly because they just get anyone to answer. You ask "is chicken skin good for a dog" half the people who never owned a dog and know nothing about nutrition will say 'yes it's great."

Invisible talker says:

Atheism is a lack of belief in gods. As such it is the default position since when faced with a truth-claim the logical default is not to believe it.

Some atheists might go farther and believe there are no gods, but that is in excess of not believing in them. Thus the most inclusive definition of atheism, not believing in any gods, is the best IMHO.
Confronted with a truth claim "the logical appraoch" is the default to not believe, why is that logical? I confront you with the truth claim "It is wrong to kill" Is that something you feel is only logical to doubt as an automatic position? why?

Acid Zebra

Lack of belief in godS. godSSSSSSSSSSS.

What is it with religious people and ignoring the ~3700 other god-notions in these type of arguments? "God". Seriously.

It is what happens when someone tells you about all these gods and you think "what nonsense, are these warm fuzzy feelings and this old book of myth all you got?". You've considered the claim, and rejected it. It isn't a belief in itself as much as your lack of belief in leprechauns or schnnztlypops isn't a belief.

This statement makes no sense at all. He's talking about "You've considered the claim, and rejected it" that's not a default. He thinks plurality of God concepts cancel each other out which also makes no sense. It's much more logical to assume that people can mistaken in their ideas of God but still be right about the thing in general.


Derek

Delusions have to be instilled. The default assumption with no cultural indoctrination or peer pressure would be reality: atheism. Or, to phrase it more as you did, neither a "belief that X" nor a "lack of belief that X," but simply the absence of fantastical notions of deities.

Of course this guys' statement is ignorant hateful stupidity. It's disproved by teh innate religous instinct argumetn. Since it's not intellied it can't be called "delusion" The use of that term is just a point of Orwellian atheism where they change the meaning of the word to fit their propaganda. Whatever disagrees with my propaganda is insanity. That's about as Totalitarian as you can get. The KGB would be proud of them.

Fire

Mankind is over two MILLION years old and Christianity just two thousand years old so it is definitely the default!
That's typical of them to assume Christianity is the really only religion. They are really just reactionaries against Christianity. They don't care about Rege or Janism or Shinto they are not out to stop Kamies in Shinto. Humanity has had some from of religious instinct all along. The Neanderthals had it (see link to Metacrock's blog at the top).